I’m not thenakedginger, but I prefer humiliation where the guy is (temporarily) aware of whatever gay thing he’s doing, but unable to stop. Like, the MC might command the guy give him a blowjob, and the guy can’t stop from getting on his knees and tugging out the MC’s dick. Like in Edlam’s newest story, when Desmond makes Frank lick his son’s cum off the table, and Frank is disgusted, but can’t stop from licking up every sticky glob. Or in the first chapter of your story Prom Night, when Caspar makes Mr.C strip naked and watch while Caspar gets sucked off by Mr.C’s son.
Although, I do prefer it to be temporary, It can be a great short-term punishment for a homophobe, or even just a normal guy, but I like the MC to have a willing or mindless sex partner by the end of the story. Also, obliviousness is an even bigger turn on for me. When a guy has been hypnotized to not realize that another guy is fucking him, or when he things that gay sex or being a slave is just a normal part of everyday life, that’s incredibly hot. A great example of this is Closing Time by Redsylph